Classic Mississippi Mud Ice Cream

This Classic Mississippi Mud Ice Cream Pie brings together the cool creamy comfort of coffee ice cream layered with rich chocolate fudge and nestled over a crisp cookie crust The first bite feels like summer barbecues and holiday gatherings at once and it never fails to wow a table of friends or family

I started making this pie for birthday parties and now it is constantly requested as a make ahead treat for family get togethers It is as easy to make as it is impressive

Ingredients

• Coffee ice cream: The coffee flavor balances all the sweetness and keeps the pie from tasting one note Look for a brand with a rich pronounced coffee taste and minimal ice crystals
• Chocolate fudge topping: This fudgy layer provides gooey pockets throughout Use a high quality thick fudge sauce for best results Avoid thin syrupy types
• Crushed Oreo cookies: These form the classic crunchy crust and also add chocolatey crunch on top Aim for fresh cookies with a crisp snap

Step by Step Instructions

Make the crust:

Firmly press the crushed Oreo cookies into the bottom of your pie dish making an even layer and smoothing up the edges for a sturdy shell Freeze the crust until completely firm which takes about thirty minutes

Prepare the first ice cream layer:

Let half of your coffee ice cream soften for about ten minutes until spreadable Blend in half of the chocolate fudge topping using a spoon or spatula Stir gently so you get fudgy ribbons instead of a uniform color Spread this mixture evenly over your cold crust and freeze for at least two hours until hard to the touch

Add the second ice cream layer:

Soften the remaining coffee ice cream as before and gently spread it over the first chilled layer Smooth the top with a spatula and return the pie to the freezer for another two hours

Finish with toppings:

Take the last of the chocolate fudge topping and drizzle or spread it over the final set layer Sprinkle extra crushed Oreo cookies over the top for a beautiful crunchy finish Freeze everything for at least two more hours or overnight for easiest serving and clean slices

Pin it

I always look forward to sprinkling those last bits of crushed cookies over the top because it reminds me of making birthday cakes with my kids The fudge topping is my favorite part when it sets into perfectly chewy chunks atop the cold pie

Storage Tips

Keep the finished pie tightly wrapped in foil or plastic wrap in the freezer for up to a week For serving let it sit at room temperature for five to ten minutes for easier slicing Always use a sharp knife dipped in hot water to get neat wedges

Ingredient Substitutions

You can use chocolate or vanilla ice cream instead of coffee if you prefer a milder flavor For the crust try chocolate graham crackers or gluten free sandwich cookies for a different texture and to meet dietary needs Store bought fudge topping works perfectly but you can make your own for an extra touch

Serving Suggestions

Serve this pie with a dollop of whipped cream and a sprinkle of chocolate shavings or fresh berries For summer events add a scoop of extra ice cream alongside the slice For an adult twist drizzle with a little coffee liqueur before serving

Pin it

A Fun History

Mississippi Mud Pie comes from the Southern United States and was named for its dark gooey look that resembles the banks of the Mississippi River Modern versions layer in ice cream for an even more decadent treat My family loves this ice cream version for its playful texture and the cool refreshing bite at the end of a barbecue

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use a different flavor of ice cream?

Yes, while coffee ice cream gives traditional flavor, you can substitute with chocolate, vanilla, or even caramel for a twist.

→ How do I keep the crust from getting soggy?

Freeze the cookie crust until firm before adding the ice cream layers. This helps maintain a crisp, crunchy base.

→ What's the best way to slice the pie?

Use a sharp knife dipped in hot water for cleaner slices. Wipe the blade between each cut for neat portions.

→ Can it be made ahead of time?

Absolutely. In fact, freezing it overnight enhances the texture, making it perfect for prepping before an event.

→ Are there topping suggestions beyond crushed cookies?

Try adding whipped cream, chocolate shavings, or toasted nuts for extra flavor and an elegant finish.