Pizza Grilled Cheese Mashup

This pizza grilled cheese is my go to for those nights when I want all the comfort of a cheesy pizza without any of the fuss or waiting. It takes the best parts of a classic grilled cheese sandwich and infuses them with the pepperoni, sauce, and Italian spices we all love, creating a truly spectacular meal in minutes.

I first threw this together for a quick lunch one day, and now it's a regular request from my family. It feels like a special treat every single time we make it.

Ingredients

• Four slices of sturdy bread: sourdough or a thick cut Italian loaf works best to prevent sogginess
• Two tablespoons of unsalted butter: softened so it's easy to mix and spread for that perfect golden crust
• Two tablespoons of grated Parmesan cheese: this adds a fantastic nutty, salty bite to the outside of the bread
• One teaspoon of Italian seasoning: for that classic pizza herb flavor we all crave
• One half teaspoon of garlic powder: a little goes a long way to make the butter spread irresistible
• A pinch of salt: to bring all the savory flavors together
• One half cup of shredded mozzarella cheese: choose a low moisture mozzarella for the best melt and that glorious cheese pull
• One quarter cup of pizza or marinara sauce: use your favorite jarred sauce for ultimate convenience
• Twelve slices of pepperoni: go for a thinly sliced variety so it layers nicely inside the sandwich

Step-by-Step Instructions

Create the Garlic Butter Spread:

In a small bowl, thoroughly mix your softened butter, grated Parmesan, Italian seasoning, garlic powder, and salt. You want it to become a smooth, spreadable paste. Making sure the butter is truly soft is the secret here; it helps all the seasonings mix in perfectly without clumping.

Assemble the Sandwiches:

Lay out all four slices of bread on your counter. On two of the slices, spread a thin, even layer of your pizza sauce, making sure to leave a small border around the edges to prevent it from spilling out. Pile on the shredded mozzarella cheese, then arrange your pepperoni slices on top. Place the remaining two slices of bread on top to complete the sandwiches.

Butter the Exterior:

Take that incredible garlic butter you made and generously spread it on the outside of each sandwich, covering the top slices from edge to edge. This is the step that creates that unforgettable crispy, savory, and golden brown crust.

Grill to Golden Perfection:

Heat a large skillet or nonstick pan over medium heat. Once hot, carefully place the sandwiches in the pan, butter side down. Let them cook for about three to four minutes, until the bottom is a deep golden brown. While the first side is cooking, spread the remaining garlic butter on the top side of the sandwiches. Flip them carefully and cook for another three to four minutes. I like to gently press down with a spatula to encourage the cheese to melt into a glorious, gooey layer.

Rest and Serve:

Once both sides are perfectly golden and you can see the cheese is completely melted, remove the sandwiches from the pan. Let them rest on a cutting board for just a minute or two. This small step is important because it helps the cheese set slightly so it doesn't all spill out when you slice into it. Cut the sandwiches in half and serve them immediately with extra marinara sauce on the side for dipping.

Pin it

For me, the garlic Parmesan butter is what elevates this from a simple sandwich to something truly special. The first time I smelled it toasting in the pan, I knew this recipe was an absolute keeper. It reminds me of the flavorful crust from my favorite childhood pizzeria.

Storage and Reheating

If you happen to have leftovers, wrap them tightly or place them in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to two days. To bring back that amazing crispy texture, be sure to skip the microwave, which will only make it soggy. The best way to reheat the sandwich is in a dry skillet over low heat for a few minutes on each side until it's warmed all the way through and crispy again.

Ingredient Substitutions

Feel free to make this recipe your own. Provolone, cheddar, or a blend of Italian cheeses would be delicious in place of the mozzarella for a different flavor profile. For a vegetarian version, you can simply omit the pepperoni or use sautéed sliced mushrooms and bell peppers instead. While sourdough is my favorite for its tangy flavor and sturdy texture, any hearty bread like a thick cut whole wheat or ciabatta will work beautifully.

Serving Suggestions

This sandwich is certainly a meal in itself, but it’s even better with a sidekick for dipping. A small bowl of warm marinara or pizza sauce is a must. If you want to make it a more complete meal, try pairing it with a simple green salad tossed in a light vinaigrette or a warm cup of creamy tomato soup for the ultimate comfort food experience.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What kind of bread works best for pizza grilled cheese?

Sturdy bread like sourdough or Italian bread holds the filling well. Whole wheat adds a nutty flavor and extra fiber.

→ Can I use different cheeses in my pizza grilled cheese?

Absolutely! Cheddar, provolone, or an Italian cheese blend are all great options. Experiment and find your favorite combination.

→ How can I make this grilled cheese vegetarian?

Simply omit the pepperoni or use a plant-based pepperoni alternative. You can also add extra vegetables like mushrooms or bell peppers.

→ What other toppings can I add to pizza grilled cheese?

Sliced mushrooms, olives, bell peppers, or a sprinkle of red pepper flakes can enhance the flavor. Get creative with your favorite pizza toppings!

→ How should I store leftover grilled cheese?

Store leftovers in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 2 days. Reheat in a dry skillet over low heat to maintain crispness.

→ What's the best way to get the cheese perfectly melted?

Cook the sandwich over medium heat and gently press down with a spatula. This helps the bread brown evenly and the cheese melt completely.