Tomato Grilled Cheese Sandwich

I discovered the ultimate summer comfort food that combines two classics in one amazing sandwich! This Tomato Grilled Cheese takes all the nostalgic flavors of grilled cheese and tomato soup but transforms them into a perfect hot-weather meal. By tucking juicy summer tomatoes and bright basil pesto between melty cheese and crispy bread, you get all those comforting flavors without having to eat soup when it's 90 degrees outside. I've made this three times in the past week and can't get enough!

I served these at a casual backyard gathering last weekend, and my friend Steve (who claims he makes the best grilled cheese in town) actually asked for my recipe. That's when I knew this sandwich was truly something special!

Essential Ingredients

Bread Basics

Sturdy sourdough holds up best to the juicy tomatoes without getting soggy. A heartier bread like multi-grain or rye adds wonderful texture and flavor. Avoid super-soft white bread that will collapse under the weight of the fillings. Whatever bread you choose, make sure the slices aren't cut too thick or the cheese won't melt properly.

Tomato Selection

Local, in-season tomatoes make all the difference in this sandwich. Roma tomatoes offer great flavor and aren't too watery for sandwiches. Beefsteak tomatoes have that perfect "meaty" quality that stands up to cooking. Heirloom varieties add beautiful color and unique flavors if you can find them.

Cheese Choices

Aged white cheddar brings a sharp, tangy flavor that balances the sweet tomatoes. A mix of cheeses works beautifully - try half cheddar, half mozzarella for the perfect melt. Pre-shredded cheese works in a pinch, but freshly grated melts more smoothly. The cheese creates a protective barrier between the bread and tomatoes, preventing sogginess.

I tried making this once with regular grocery store tomatoes in the winter, and it just wasn't the same. This is definitely a sandwich that shines with peak-season produce. I grow my own tomatoes and basil in the summer, and there's nothing like making this sandwich with ingredients I just picked minutes before!

Pin it

Simple Preparation

Mayo Magic

The secret to a perfectly crispy exterior isn't butter—it's mayonnaise! Spread a thin layer of mayo on the outside of your bread instead of butter. It creates the most beautiful golden-brown crust with a subtle tang that elevates the whole sandwich. Don't worry if you're not a mayo fan—it doesn't taste mayo-ish after cooking, it just creates the perfect texture.

Assembly Strategy

Start by heating your skillet over medium heat while you build your sandwich. Spread mayo on the outside of one bread slice and place it mayo-side down in the pan. Working quickly, spread basil pesto on the inside of that slice, then add half your cheese, followed by tomato slices (don't forget to season them with fresh pepper!), then the remaining cheese. Finally, top with the second slice of bread and spread mayo on the outside-facing side.

Cooking Technique

Cook for 3-4 minutes on the first side until golden brown, then carefully flip and cook another 3-4 minutes on the second side. The key is medium heat—too high and your bread will burn before the cheese melts, too low and everything gets soggy. You want that perfect balance where the bread gets crispy and golden while giving the cheese enough time to melt completely.

I learned the hard way about flipping tomato-filled sandwiches—they can be slippery! Now I use the plate-flip method described in the recipe, and it works perfectly every time. Just lift the sandwich onto a plate, top with another plate, flip, and slide it back into the pan. No more tomato casualties!

My first attempt at this sandwich was a bit disappointing because I used too much pesto, which overwhelmed the other flavors. Now I use just a thin layer—enough to taste but not so much that it takes over. It's all about finding that perfect balance where each ingredient shines.

Perfect Pairings

This sandwich is hearty enough to be a meal on its own, but I love serving it with some simple sides to round things out. A handful of kettle chips adds the perfect salty crunch to contrast with the creamy sandwich. In summer, I'll add a light side salad with a vinaigrette dressing to balance the richness of the grilled cheese. For drinks, an ice-cold lemonade or iced tea is perfect on a hot day. If you're serving this for dinner, a crisp white wine like Sauvignon Blanc or a light beer complements the flavors beautifully without overwhelming them. During cooler months, you can actually serve this alongside a small cup of tomato soup for dipping—the ultimate comfort food combination taken to the next level!

Creative Variations

While the classic version is perfect on its own, this sandwich is easy to customize based on what you have on hand. Try adding crispy bacon for a BLT-meets-grilled-cheese experience that's absolutely amazing. Thinly sliced avocado adds creaminess that works wonderfully with the tomato and pesto. For an Italian twist, add a few thin slices of pepperoni or salami between the tomato and cheese layers. The spicy meat adds another dimension of flavor that pairs beautifully with the basil pesto. If you're not a fan of pesto or don't have any on hand, try spreading a thin layer of sun-dried tomato spread instead—it intensifies the tomato flavor and adds a nice sweetness to the sandwich.

Pin it

Chef's Notes

Bread Thickness: Slice your bread about 1/2-inch thick—too thin and it will get soggy, too thick and your cheese won't melt properly. Temperature Control: Keep your heat at medium and be patient—the perfect grilled cheese can't be rushed. Tomato Prep: Pat your tomato slices with a paper towel before adding them to remove excess moisture and prevent a soggy sandwich.

This Tomato Grilled Cheese Sandwich has completely changed my summer lunch game. It's that perfect balance of nostalgic comfort food and seasonal freshness that satisfies cravings while still feeling appropriate for hot weather. The combination of melty cheese, juicy tomatoes, and aromatic pesto between crispy bread is simply unbeatable. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch, a simple dinner, or even a midnight snack, this elevated grilled cheese delivers every time.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use a different type of bread?

Absolutely! While sourdough provides great flavor and texture, you can substitute with any sturdy bread like country white, whole grain, or ciabatta.

→ Why use mayonnaise instead of butter on the outside?

Mayo spreads more easily than butter and creates an incredibly crispy, golden exterior. It also adds a subtle tangy flavor that complements the sandwich.

→ Can I use store-bought pesto?

Yes, any quality store-bought pesto works great. For the best flavor, look for refrigerated options rather than shelf-stable ones.

→ What's the best cheese to use?

Aged cheddar provides great flavor and meltability, but you could also try Gruyère, fontina, or a mix of mozzarella and Parmesan for different flavor profiles.

→ How do I prevent my sandwich from getting soggy from the tomatoes?

Pat the tomato slices with a paper towel to remove excess moisture before adding them to your sandwich. Also, placing cheese on both sides of the tomato creates a barrier.