Cheesy Chicken Pockets

Man, these chicken Alfredo calzones have totally turned my crazy weeknights around! I found this idea last summer when I needed something quick that wouldn't trash my entire kitchen. When I served them the first time, my teenage son actually stopped scrolling on his phone and wanted more - that never happens! There's this awesome thing about the crispy outer shell meeting that melty, cheesy chicken inside that makes everyone grab seconds. And they only take like 20 minutes start-to-finish in the air fryer, which feels like pure magic when you're rushing around.

When my sister came by with her super picky kid who usually only eats plain noodles and chicken tenders, I was stuck for meal ideas until these calzones popped into my head. I got her daughter to help fold and press the edges, and guess what? She wolfed down a whole calzone and begged to make them again tomorrow! My sister has texted me multiple times asking how to make them because now her daughter won't stop asking for them. Can't say I feel bad about it!

What You'll Need

• Ready-made pizza dough: cuts down on prep time and honestly works better than from-scratch for these. Those Pillsbury tubes surprisingly do the trick, but grabbing dough from the grocery deli gives you a nicer chew.
• Deli rotisserie chicken: isn't cutting corners - it's being smart. The light seasoning adds flavor without extra work, and the texture stays just right in the filling.
• Pre-made Alfredo sauce: keeps me from losing my mind on busy nights. I stumbled on the fact that Classico brand tastes almost exactly like my grandma's time-consuming recipe. That jar in my fridge has gotten me through countless dinner emergencies.
• Blend of three cheeses: isn't something I'll budge on. I tried going simpler with just mozzarella but adding ricotta brings amazing creaminess while parmesan gives that punch that makes these taste like you paid good money for them.
• Italian seasoning: from my super old spice shelf somehow ties everything together. I know I could probably mix my own, but that ancient McCormick container from who-knows-when does the job perfectly.

I used to feel a bit bad about using shortcuts until my cousin with actual culinary training admitted she uses jarred Alfredo for family dinners too. Now I just welcome the time-savers because nobody has ever turned down these calzones, even my foodie friends who keep asking me for the recipe like it's some complicated thing!

Pin it

Easy Preparation Steps

Mix Your Filling:

Take a large bowl and combine your pulled rotisserie chicken with the Alfredo sauce. Toss in all three cheeses, add the garlic powder and Italian seasoning, sprinkle some salt and pepper, then mix until it all comes together. These days I mostly eyeball the amounts based on how many folks I'm feeding.

Handle The Dough:

Open that tube of pizza dough that still makes me jump every time or spread out your deli dough on a floured surface. Cut into four pieces and stretch each one into rough circles. Don't worry if they look more like blobs than perfect rounds.

Fill Them Up:

Put big scoops of filling onto one half of each dough circle. I usually go with about a heaping 1/3 cup for each but really just do what looks right. Keep about half an inch clear around the edges for sealing.

Seal The Deal:

Pull the empty half of dough over your filling to create a half-moon. Push the edges together with a fork to lock everything in. This step feels oddly relaxing, especially after a tough day at work.

Add Some Shine:

Brush or rub olive oil all over the outside. Don't miss this step! It's what gives you that beautiful golden color and crunchy outside. Poke a few tiny holes in the top with a fork so they don't burst in the air fryer.

The first batch I ever made went in my regular oven which took ages and turned my kitchen into a sweatbox. Then my neighbor let me borrow her air fryer after our block party when I was whining about my hot kitchen after a few glasses of wine, and I've been hooked since. The air fryer gets the outside perfectly crisp while keeping everything inside hot and gooey in way less time.

These calzones have become our unofficial Friday tradition at my house. My daughter started asking friends over specifically when we're having calzones, which I act annoyed about but secretly love. Last Friday she brought three teammates home after soccer, and they ate eight calzones in what seemed like minutes. One mom texted asking where I'd ordered from, which might be the nicest thing anyone's said about my cooking.

Perfect Side Matches

These puffy golden pouches stand on their own, but I usually toss together a quick side salad just so I can feel like we're getting some veggies. Just grab whatever greens are in the fridge with any leftover vegetables and a splash of balsamic dressing. When I'm feeling fancy, I'll heat up extra Alfredo sauce in a small dish for dipping, which my husband claims is too much but does anyway.

When friends come over casually, I make tiny versions using canned biscuit dough instead of pizza dough and put out marinara and pesto for dipping. They vanish super fast, and everyone thinks they took way more effort than they did. My brother's wife still believes they're some treasured family recipe I work hard on, and I've never bothered telling her the truth.

Creative Twists

I've come up with so many versions of these that my family now asks for them by nickname. The Dad version has hot Italian sausage instead of chicken because my husband dumps hot sauce on everything he eats. My son's basketball buddies go nuts for the buffalo chicken option where I mix the shredded chicken with buffalo sauce and swap in a bit of ranch and blue cheese instead of Alfredo.

My own favorite twist happened by chance when I was using up leftovers and threw in some sun dried tomatoes, spinach, and feta with the chicken and just a little Alfredo sauce. It turned into this amazing Mediterranean flavor that I now make on purpose whenever I want something slightly lighter but still filling.

Using Up Extras

If by some miracle you actually have leftovers, they stay pretty good in the fridge for a couple days. Just wrap in foil and warm up in the air fryer for about 3 minutes at 350°F. The microwave works if you're in a hurry but makes the outside kind of soft and floppy instead of crispy.

I've started making twice as many and freezing the put-together but uncooked calzones wrapped separately in plastic then foil. On super busy nights, I just unwrap and toss them straight from freezer to air fryer, adding about 5 more minutes to cook time. This trick honestly saved me during basketball season when we had practice four nights weekly and everyone walked in hungry enough to eat the furniture.

Pin it

I never thought a simple weeknight dinner hack would turn into my go-to dish, but these calzones have shown up at potlucks, team dinners, and even made it into our neighborhood cookbook. They've given me a rep as someone who knows what they're doing in the kitchen, which couldn't be more wrong! But I'll take the praise while quietly thanking my air fryer, grocery rotisserie chicken, and store-bought dough for doing the real work. Sometimes the best meals aren't about cooking skills but finding that magic combo of shortcuts that somehow makes something way better than you'd expect.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I bake these in a normal oven?

Totally! Bake them at 425°F for 12-15 minutes till golden. The texture might not be as crisp as when air fried.

→ What’s an alternative to store-bought dough?

Homemade pizza dough works. Crescent roll dough or puff pastry can give a fun twist too.

→ Can I prep these in advance?

The filling can be made a day early. Put them together and cook fresh for the best crunch.

→ What pairs well with these pockets?

Try pairing with a green salad, roasted veggies, or buttery garlic knots for a complete meal.

→ How do I store and warm up leftovers?

Keep them in the fridge for up to 3 days. Reheat in the air fryer at 350°F for about 3-4 minutes to crisp them back up.