Cheesy Baked Shrimp

Pasta comfort can't be topped, particularly when it's packed with juicy shrimp and coated in a buttery sauce with hints of garlic and lemon. This baked shrimp scampi pasta takes your regular stovetop meal and turns it into something even more wonderful in your oven. The cheese gets all gooey and brown, flavors blend together, and you wind up with a dish that seems fancy but doesn't need any special cooking skills.

I first put together this dish after a party cooking flop where I tried making individual portions of shrimp scampi for eight guests and wound up with a mix of overdone and raw shrimp. This oven version lets you set everything up once, and your oven handles the work while you actually chat with your company.

Essential Elements

• Pasta With Texture: Skip the usual linguine for this casserole – pick shapes with little pockets that catch all that delicious sauce. I always go for cavatappi or cellentani since those twists seem made for holding onto saucy goodness.
• Shrimp: Go for bigger sizes, and don't stress about buying fresh – quality frozen shrimp you thaw at home often taste just as yummy. Just grab ones already peeled and cleaned to make life easier.
• Butter and Olive Oil: These two work together to make that classic scampi base. Don't cut corners here – this isn't meant to be light fare, it's meant to make you happy.
• Garlic: The list calls for 6-8 cloves, but really, go with what feels right. True garlic fans know there's no such thing as putting in too much.
• Lemon: You need both juice AND zest – that outer part has all the fragrant oils that give your dish its zippy character.

I stumbled on how amazing pasta water can be one night when I ran out of stock. That starchy stuff works like magic – it helps the sauce stick to your pasta and makes everything feel smooth. Now I save some even if recipes don't mention it.

Pin it

Quick Cooking Guide

Noodle Know-How

Cook your pasta just a bit less than al dente – it'll finish in the oven. That leftover pasta water isn't just backup; it's crucial for creating a smooth sauce that hugs every bit. Don't wash your pasta after draining – that starchy coating helps everything stick together.

Starting Your Sauce

The butter and oil make a rich foundation, while garlic adds the flavor punch. Just cook the garlic until you smell it – around 60 seconds is plenty. Burned garlic will spoil everything, so watch carefully and turn down the heat if needed.

Getting Shrimp Right

Shrimp cook super fast – only 2-4 minutes until they turn pink and curl up. The worst mistake is cooking them too long at this point. They'll cook more in the oven, so it's better to pull them early from the pan.

Smart Cheese Use

Parmesan brings the salty depth, while mozzarella gives you that stretchy pull. Mix some cheese right into the pasta blend and save the rest for topping to get flavor throughout plus a golden crust.

Oven Transformation

Time in the oven isn't just about melty cheese – it lets all those tastes come together. The sides get a bit crispy, sauce bubbles around the edges, and everything becomes better than you'd expect from the parts.

Wait Time

Those few minutes of cooling after baking aren't just to avoid burning your mouth (though that matters too). This break lets the sauce thicken up and the flavors settle down.

My first try with this dish turned out too dry because I drained all the pasta water away. Now I always set aside at least a cup, just in case. It's like backup for getting your sauce just right.

Perfect Pairings

This filling main course works great with simple sides that enhance without stealing the show. A fresh green salad with light dressing cuts through the richness really well. Garlic bread is pretty much required for soaking up every bit of that amazing sauce. For a full meal, throw in some oven-roasted asparagus or broccoli – the slight charring goes really well with the lemon and garlic notes.

Fun Variations

Change up this basic dish with easy add-ins that create totally different meals. Toss in a couple handfuls of fresh spinach when mixing everything together – it'll cook down perfectly in the oven. To amp up the taste, mix in some sun-dried tomatoes or artichoke hearts. Seafood lovers might enjoy adding scallops or chunks of firm white fish with the shrimp. For extra richness, stir in a bit of cream cheese with the sauce for an even creamier result.

Prep Beforehand

While this dish tastes best when put together and baked right before eating, you can get many pieces ready ahead of time. Chop up the garlic, prep the lemon, and shred the cheese up to a day early. You can even cook the sauce base (stopping before the shrimp goes in) and keep it in the fridge. If you really need to build the whole dish ahead, add an extra 10-15 minutes to cooking time if it's coming straight from the cold fridge.

Using Extras

If you're lucky enough to have some left, it'll stay good in the fridge for 3-4 days. Warm it up gently so the shrimp don't get tough – using a covered dish in a 325°F oven works great. Add a splash of water if it looks dry. This meal doesn't freeze well because of the seafood and dairy, so plan to finish it within a few days.

Pin it

I've been tweaking versions of this shrimp scampi pasta bake for ages, slowly improving the amounts and methods. What began as a way to serve seafood to many people has turned into one of my go-to dishes that everyone asks for by name. There's something really wonderful about watching guests go quiet when they take their first bite, then immediately reach for more. Those peaceful moments when people truly enjoy the food make cooking for others so worthwhile.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I swap pre-cooked shrimp in this?

Yes, but fresh works better! If using pre-cooked shrimp, stir them in last during the sauce step and skip any extra cooking. They'll finish warming in the oven without turning chewy.

→ What’s the ideal pasta for this?

Choose pasta with curves or grooves—think penne, rotini, or cavatappi. These catch the sauce better than longer noodles like linguine, though you can use those if you'd like.

→ How can I make a lighter version?

Try whole wheat pasta, cut back on butter, add more olive oil, and pile in veggies like spinach or broccoli. Use less cheese, skip mozzarella, or serve a smaller plate with a big side salad.

→ Can this be prepared ahead?

Yes, but bake just before eating for the best texture. You can chop the garlic, zest the lemon, and grate the cheese ahead. If assembling fully, refrigerate, then bake while adding extra time to accommodate the chill.

→ How should I store and reheat extras?

Let leftovers cool, cover tightly, and refrigerate for 3-4 days. Warm them in the oven covered with foil or briefly in the microwave with a bit of water to keep the shrimp tender.

→ What can I add for extra substance?

You can toss in veggies like spinach, peas, or broccoli, or some cooked chicken chunks for protein. Cream cheese adds richness, or sprinkle breadcrumbs on top for crunch.