Air Fryer Pizza Toast

The night I discovered pizza toast was the night my relationship with my air fryer changed forever. It was midnight, I was starving, and the thought of waiting 45 minutes for delivery made me want to cry. Desperate times call for desperate measures, so I grabbed what I had – bread, that half-jar of pizza sauce in the fridge, and some cheese that needed using up. Five minutes later, I was biting into something so ridiculously satisfying that I actually laughed out loud in my empty kitchen. This air fryer pizza toast has since rescued countless hungry nights, impromptu gatherings, and those dangerous moments when pizza cravings hit but patience is nowhere to be found.

When my best friend came over after a rough breakup, I made her these instead of ice cream, and she said they were better therapy. There's something about that combination of crispy, cheesy comfort food that fixes almost anything – at least temporarily.

Secret Ingredient Picks

• Sturdy Bread - Forget flimsy sandwich bread. You want something with substance – sourdough, ciabatta, or a thick-cut white bread. My personal favorite is day-old sourdough because those air pockets crisp up beautifully.
• Thick Pizza Sauce - The watery jarred stuff will make your toast soggy. Either use a thick brand (Rao's is my go-to) or simmer regular sauce for a few minutes to reduce it. In desperate times, I've even used thick salsa with Italian seasonings mixed in.
• Block Mozzarella - Take the extra minute to shred your own. The pre-shredded bags have anti-caking agents that prevent that glorious cheese stretch we all crave. A mix of mozzarella and sharp cheddar gives the perfect flavor balance.
• Fresh Garlic - Rub a cut clove directly on the toasted bread before adding sauce. This subtle addition makes people wonder why your pizza toast tastes so much better than theirs.
• Quality Olive Oil - A light drizzle over the top just before air frying adds richness and helps everything brown beautifully.
• Dried Oregano - Not the container that's been in your cabinet since 2018. Fresh dried herbs make a massive difference – rub them between your fingers to wake up the oils before sprinkling.
• Red Pepper Flakes - Just a pinch adds dimension without making it spicy. Even my heat-averse friends don't notice it's there, but they do notice when it's missing.
• Finishing Salt - A light sprinkle of flaky sea salt after cooking brightens all the flavors. Trust me on this one.

Pin it

Quick Cooking Method

Prep Your Base

Start by lightly toasting your bread slices in the air fryer for about 2 minutes at 350°F. This creates a barrier that prevents the sauce from making things soggy. While the bread pre-toasts, take that minute to gather your toppings and shred your cheese.

Create Your Canvas

Once pre-toasted, rub the bread with a cut garlic clove for that subtle background flavor that makes all the difference. Then spread a generous but not excessive layer of pizza sauce, leaving a small border around the edges that will become gloriously crispy.

Cheese Strategy

Contrary to instinct, sprinkle a light layer of cheese first, add your toppings, then finish with more cheese. This "cheese sandwich" method locks toppings in place and prevents them from burning or flying around in the air fryer.

Seasoning Magic

Dust with dried oregano, a pinch of red pepper flakes, and a very light drizzle of good olive oil. The oil helps everything brown perfectly and adds a richness that takes this from good to "why is this so addictive?"

Perfect Timing

Air fry at 370°F for exactly 5 minutes. This is the sweet spot where the cheese melts completely, the edges get crispy, and the bottom becomes perfectly golden. If your air fryer runs hot, check at 4 minutes by carefully lifting an edge with a spatula.

Finishing Touch

Let it rest for one minute before cutting or biting in (I know it's hard). This allows the cheese to set slightly so it doesn't all slide off with the first bite. A light sprinkle of fresh herbs or that flaky sea salt right now makes all the difference.

My coworker brought pepperoni to work specifically to make this in our break room air fryer. Now we have "Pizza Toast Thursdays" where everyone brings different toppings to share. It's become the most attended optional meeting on our calendar.

Daily Delights

Transform a regular movie night into something special by setting up a pizza toast bar. Prepare several bases and let everyone add their own toppings before taking turns with the air fryer. It's interactive, fun, and creates way less mess than trying to make actual pizza dough. My family does this at least once a month, and it's always a hit.

For a quick but impressive appetizer, make mini versions using baguette slices. Top them with caramelized onions, a little blue cheese, and a drizzle of honey after cooking. These fancy bites disappear in seconds at gatherings, and no one needs to know they took almost no effort to make.

When you need a complete meal, serve two slices of pizza toast with a simple side salad dressed with lemon and olive oil. The bright acidity of the salad perfectly balances the richness of the toast. I often do this for lunch when working from home – it feels like a treat but takes less time than making a sandwich.

Tasty Twists

Breakfast Version

Use a thin layer of salsa instead of pizza sauce, then top with scrambled eggs, crumbled bacon, and cheddar cheese. The breakfast pizza toast that results is seriously good enough to get me out of bed early.

Mediterranean Style

Spread toast with pesto instead of red sauce, then top with artichoke hearts, olives, feta, and a light sprinkle of mozzarella. After cooking, add fresh arugula tossed with lemon juice and a few shavings of parmesan.

Dessert Adaptation

Spread sliced bread with Nutella, top with thinly sliced strawberries and mini marshmallows. Air fry for just 3 minutes until marshmallows are golden and gooey. It's like s'mores pizza and absolutely worth the extra toothbrushing.

Smart Storage

Reality Check

Let's be honest – these are best eaten immediately. Nothing compares to that just-made crispiness. However, life happens, and sometimes storage is necessary.

If you need to make these ahead of time, the best approach is to prepare everything but air fry for only 3 minutes. This gets the cooking started but doesn't finish it. Store in the refrigerator, then finish with another 3 minutes in the air fryer when ready to eat.

For already cooked leftovers, refrigerate in an airtight container for up to 2 days. Reheat in the air fryer for 2-3 minutes at 350°F to restore some crispness. Avoid the microwave unless you enjoy eating what amounts to a pizza-flavored kitchen sponge.

If you're meal prepping, I recommend preparing the components separately – pre-toasting the bread, storing the sauce and toppings separately, and assembling right before cooking. This takes only a minute longer but makes a huge difference in quality.

Pin it

Chef Tips

Cheese Shield

If using fresh herbs like basil, place them under the final layer of cheese to prevent them from burning.

Crust Enhancer

Brush the edges with garlic butter before air frying for an extra flavor boost that mimics garlic knots.

Clean Cut

Use kitchen scissors instead of a knife for cleaner cuts that don't drag all the cheese off.

Last month during that massive power outage, our gas stove wasn't working, but our generator could handle the air fryer. I made batch after batch of these pizza toasts for neighbors who gathered at our house. Something about sharing this simple comfort food during a stressful time created a sense of normalcy and community. People still mention those "blackout pizza toasts" when I see them around town. Sometimes the simplest recipes create the strongest memories.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What type of bread works best for pizza toast?

Almost any bread works, but thicker slices like Texas toast, sourdough, or Italian bread hold up best to the sauce and toppings. Regular sandwich bread works too, but may not get quite as crispy.

→ Can I make this without an air fryer?

Yes! You can make pizza toast in a regular oven using the broiler setting. Place on a baking sheet and broil for 3-5 minutes, watching carefully so it doesn't burn. A toaster oven also works well at 375°F for about 8 minutes.

→ What other toppings can I use?

The options are endless! Try cooked sausage, ham, bacon, mushrooms, bell peppers, olives, pineapple, or any of your favorite pizza toppings. Just be sure not to overload the bread or it may become soggy.

→ Can I use something other than pizza sauce?

Absolutely! Try pesto, alfredo sauce, BBQ sauce, or even just a drizzle of olive oil with garlic as your base. Each creates a different but equally delicious pizza toast variation.

→ How do I keep the bread from getting soggy?

To prevent soggy bread, don't use too much sauce and consider toasting the bread lightly before adding toppings. Also, use room temperature toppings rather than cold ones straight from the refrigerator.