Pin it
Pizza cravings hit differently when you've discovered the magic of homemade roll ups in your air fryer. After countless attempts at recreating my kids' favorite pizza snacks, I stumbled upon this gem of a recipe that's become our family's go-to for movie nights and impromptu gatherings. These pizza roll ups bring together melty cheese, zesty pepperoni, and crispy tortillas in a way that'll make you forget about delivery.
The first time I made these for my daughter's slumber party, they disappeared so fast I had to make a second batch. Now I always make extra because my husband keeps stealing them while they're cooling!
Essential Ingredients Explained
- Flour Tortillas: Trust me on this - grab the 8-inch ones. I've tried larger sizes, but they just don't crisp up the same way
- Pizza Sauce: Go for the thick stuff. I learned the hard way that watery sauce makes soggy roll ups
- String Cheese: Don't get fancy here - the regular mozzarella string cheese creates that perfect pizza pull
- Pepperoni: Regular-sized slices work best, mini ones tend to fall out during rolling
- Olive Oil: A light brush makes these golden and crispy. I've tried spray oil, but brush-on gives better results
Pin it
Let's Make Some Roll Ups
- Prep Your Station:
- Get everything lined up before you start - trust me, it makes the whole process smoother
- Warm Those Tortillas:
- Thirty seconds between damp paper towels makes them perfectly pliable
- Sauce It Up:
- Spread a spoonful of sauce near the bottom edge, leaving room for rolling
- Add The Good Stuff:
- Layer your pepperoni in a row, followed by your halved string cheese
- Roll With It:
- Fold in the sides slightly and roll tightly from the bottom up
- Seal The Deal:
- Brush the entire surface with olive oil, making sure to get the edges
- Air Fry Time:
- Place seam-side down and let your air fryer work its magic
I've messed up countless roll ups learning these lessons so you don't have to. Looking back, using pre-shredded cheese was my biggest rookie mistake - it just doesn't melt right compared to string cheese. My teenage son still teases me about the "cheese explosion incident of 2023."
Make It A Meal
Since discovering these roll ups, our Friday night dinners have gotten so much easier. I usually set up a little spread with some warmed marinara for dipping, a big Caesar salad, and maybe some garlic knots if I'm feeling ambitious. When friends drop by unexpectedly, I can whip these up in no time and look like I actually planned ahead.
Switch It Up
Some nights I raid the fridge and get creative. Last week I found some leftover grilled chicken and buffalo sauce - game changer! My kids now beg for the "pizza-dilla" version where I add a bit of taco seasoning to the sauce. Even my picky niece, who normally turns her nose up at anything resembling a vegetable, loves them stuffed with spinach and ricotta.
Keep 'Em Fresh
Nothing's worse than soggy leftovers, right? I store these beauties in a container with paper towels between layers. For reheating, forget the microwave - just trust me on this. A quick stint in the air fryer brings back that crispy exterior. Though honestly, in our house, leftovers are rare!
Pizza Night Revolution
Remember those frozen pizza rolls we grew up with? These blow them out of the water. My neighbor Katie actually started borrowing my air fryer just to make these, until her husband finally caved and bought them one for Christmas. Now our kids run between houses comparing our different variations.
Beyond Basic Pizza
Some nights I get fancy and use prosciutto instead of pepperoni, or mix in some caramelized onions. During summer, when my garden is bursting with fresh basil, I'll add a few leaves before rolling. The possibilities are endless, and somehow they all turn out delicious.
Pin it
Kitchen Wisdom
- Let them cool slightly - I know it's tempting, but molten cheese burns are no joke
- Don't skimp on the oil brush - it's what gives you that pizzeria-style crunch
- Keep those tortillas warm while working - cold ones crack and make a mess
After years of pizza-making experiments, from traditional oven-baked to grilled versions, these air fryer roll ups have earned their spot in my weekly rotation. They're perfect for those hectic weeknights when everyone's running in different directions, yet still special enough for when company comes over.
The best part? Even my mother-in-law asked for the recipe, and she's usually the one handing out cooking advice! Whether you're feeding hungry teenagers after sports practice or hosting a casual game night, these roll ups hit the spot every time. Just be prepared to make more than you think you need - they have a way of disappearing faster than you can say "pizza time!"
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why warm the tortillas first?
- Warming makes tortillas more pliable and prevents cracking when rolling. Use damp paper towel to keep them soft.
- → Can I use different fillings?
- Yes, try different cheeses, meats, or vegetables. Just keep amounts similar to avoid overfilling.
- → Why put them seam-side down?
- This helps prevent them from unrolling during cooking and seals the edge.
- → Can I make these ahead?
- Yes, assemble and store in fridge up to 4 days. Reheat in air fryer at 360°F for 1-2 minutes.
- → Why brush with oil?
- Oil helps achieve a crispy, golden-brown exterior. Don't skip this step for best results.