Pickled Pepper and Onion Relish

Pickled pepper and onion relish transforms ordinary meals into flavor adventures with its perfect balance of tangy brightness and subtle sweetness. This versatile condiment brings vibrant color and zesty punch to your table, elevating everything from backyard burgers to gourmet sandwiches with minimal effort but maximum impact.

I stumbled across this recipe years ago when trying to use up the last of my garden peppers before frost. What started as a desperate attempt to avoid waste turned into my most-requested condiment. Friends now drop by with empty jars, hoping I've made a fresh batch they can "borrow" - which is how I know it's the real deal.

Flavor-Packed Ingredients

• Bell peppers provide sweet crunch and vibrant color—mix red, yellow and orange varieties for a relish that's as beautiful as it is tasty
• Onions offer savory depth that balances the sweetness perfectly—white onions work well but red add gorgeous purple ribbons throughout
• White vinegar creates that essential tangy pickle flavor—its clean profile lets the vegetables shine
• Apple cider vinegar brings subtle fruity notes that round out the sharper vinegar—plus healthy benefits that make me feel virtuous
• Sugar balances the acidic punch with necessary sweetness—don't skimp here, it's what makes everything harmonize
• Mustard seeds add tiny pops of texture and spice that wake up your palate—these little flavor bombs are non-negotiable
• Celery seeds contribute an herbal note that's hard to identify but absolutely crucial—they're the secret weapon in this recipe
• Turmeric provides warmth and that gorgeous golden hue—plus anti-inflammatory benefits as a bonus
• Salt enhances every other flavor component—I prefer kosher for its clean taste

Pin it

Simple Preparation Method

Vegetable Prep

Start by slicing your bell peppers and onions as thinly as possible. I aim for almost translucent onion slices and pepper strips no wider than a pencil. The thin slices allow the brine to penetrate quickly and ensure each bite is perfectly pickled. Combine these in a large, heat-proof bowl and set aside while you work magic with the pickling mixture.

Brine Creation

In a sturdy saucepan, combine your vinegars, sugar, and all those wonderful spices—mustard seeds, celery seeds, turmeric, salt, black pepper, and red pepper flakes if you want that extra kick. Bring this mixture to a lively boil, stirring until the sugar completely dissolves. This heating process not only melts the sugar but also awakens the essential oils in the spices, releasing their full flavor potential.

Hot Pour Technique

Once your brine is boiling and the sugar has completely disappeared, carefully pour this hot mixture over your prepared vegetables. The heat partially cooks the peppers and onions, softening them just enough while maintaining their pleasant crunch. Stir everything thoroughly to ensure each slice is swimming in that golden liquid.

Cooling Period

Allow your creation to cool naturally at room temperature, giving it an occasional gentle stir. During this cooling period, the vegetables begin their transformation, absorbing the vibrant flavors of your spiced brine. Be patient—the magic is happening even though you can't see it.

Flavor Development

Transfer your cooled relish to clean jars or containers and refrigerate for at least 24 hours before sampling. This waiting period is crucial—the flavors mellow, meld, and mature during this time. What might taste too vinegary initially transforms into a perfectly balanced condiment after this resting period.

My father-in-law, who claims to hate anything pickled, accidentally spooned this onto his hot dog last summer and has been sneaking it onto everything since. When I caught him eating it straight from the jar with a fork, I knew I had a lifetime winner. Now I make double batches, knowing half will disappear to his house in mysteriously reused jam jars.

Serving Suggestions

This bright relish transforms an ordinary grilled cheese into something spectacular—just add a generous spoonful before closing the sandwich. For summer cookouts, offer it alongside traditional condiments for hot dogs and burgers—you'll be surprised how many guests choose it over ketchup. My personal favorite is topping a cream cheese-smeared bagel with a heap of this relish for a quick lunch that feels fancy without any real effort.

Creative Variations

Experiment with different pepper combinations—try adding a jalapeño or two for gentle heat throughout, or substitute half the bell peppers with fennel bulb for an unexpected licorice note. For a holiday version, add cranberries and orange zest to the basic recipe for a festive accompaniment to turkey or ham. During summer, I sometimes toss in fresh corn kernels cut from the cob during the last five minutes of marinating for sweet pops of texture.

Keeping It Fresh

Store your relish in clean glass jars with tight-fitting lids in the refrigerator, where it will keep beautifully for up to two weeks—though it rarely lasts that long in my house. The flavors continue developing during storage, so don't worry if you make it several days before you need it. Avoid using metal containers for storage, as the vinegar can react with some metals and affect the flavor.

Pin it

Chef's Helpful Insights

• Use a mandoline if you have one for perfectly even, thin slices that pickle uniformly
• For gift-giving, process filled jars in a water bath for 10 minutes to make them shelf-stable
• Save the leftover brine when the vegetables are gone—it makes an amazing base for salad dressing

My grandmother used to make something similar to this relish every summer, though her recipe disappeared with her. I spent years trying to recreate those flavors from memory, and this version finally captured that elusive taste of childhood summers. When my mother tried it, she got quiet for a moment, then looked at me with misty eyes and simply said, "You found it." Now it's become my tradition too, connecting generations through the simple alchemy of peppers, onions, and spice.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ How long does this relish last in the refrigerator?

The relish will keep well in the refrigerator for up to 2 weeks in airtight containers or jars.

→ Can I use different colored bell peppers?

Absolutely! Using a mix of red, yellow, orange, and green bell peppers creates a more colorful relish with varied flavors.

→ Is this recipe suitable for canning?

This recipe is designed for refrigerator storage. For proper canning and shelf stability, you'd need to follow specific canning safety guidelines.

→ Can I reduce the sugar in this recipe?

You can reduce the sugar, but it helps balance the vinegar's acidity. Start by reducing it by half and adjust to taste.

→ What can I serve this relish with?

This versatile relish is perfect for burgers, hot dogs, sandwiches, cheese boards, grilled meats, or mixed into tuna or chicken salad.

→ Can I make this less spicy?

Absolutely! Simply omit the red pepper flakes for a milder version that everyone can enjoy.